Best Crib Mattress: Your Baby Deserves The Best

Last Updated on

Milliard Crib Mattress, Flip Technology, Firm Side for Baby and Soft Side for Toddler, Hypoallergenic - 100% Cotton Cover
Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress in a Box – GREENGUARD Gold Certified, Non-Toxic, Breathable, Removable Washable Water Resistant Outer Cover
Dourxi Crib and Toddler Mattress - Ideal Breathable & Quiet Foam Mattress Airflow Sleep Surface with Removable Washable Outer Cover, Lightweight Crib Mattress
American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib and Toddler Protective Mattress Pad Cover, White (1 Count), for Boys and Girls
Dourxi Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress, Dual Sided Sleep System, Firm Side for Infants and Plush Soft Side for Toddlers, Breathable Foam Baby Mattress with Removable Cover
Score
9.4
9.5
8.7
8.6
8.4
MSRP
$69.99
$69.99
$89.99
$11.97
$109.99
Size
52 x 5.5 inches
52 x 5 inches
9.5 x 9.2 inches
52 inch x 9 inch
27.5 x 5.5 inches
Weight
9.39 lbs
10.7 lbs
10.4 lbs
0.7 lbs
11.9 lbs
Materials
Organic cotton cover, memory foam mattress
Polyurethane foam
Polyurethane foam
Polyester fleece, elastic
Organic cotton, eco foam
Cover included
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Guarantee
Not specified
6-year limited warranty
10-year warranty
Not specified
10-year warranty
Milliard Crib Mattress, Flip Technology, Firm Side for Baby and Soft Side for Toddler, Hypoallergenic - 100% Cotton Cover
Score
9.4
MSRP
$69.99
Size
52 x 5.5 inches
Weight
9.39 lbs
Materials
Organic cotton cover, memory foam mattress
Cover included
Yes
Guarantee
Not specified
Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress in a Box – GREENGUARD Gold Certified, Non-Toxic, Breathable, Removable Washable Water Resistant Outer Cover
Score
9.5
MSRP
$69.99
Size
52 x 5 inches
Weight
10.7 lbs
Materials
Polyurethane foam
Cover included
Yes
Guarantee
6-year limited warranty
Dourxi Crib and Toddler Mattress - Ideal Breathable & Quiet Foam Mattress Airflow Sleep Surface with Removable Washable Outer Cover, Lightweight Crib Mattress
Score
8.7
MSRP
$89.99
Size
9.5 x 9.2 inches
Weight
10.4 lbs
Materials
Polyurethane foam
Cover included
Yes
Guarantee
10-year warranty
American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib and Toddler Protective Mattress Pad Cover, White (1 Count), for Boys and Girls
Score
8.6
MSRP
$11.97
Size
52 inch x 9 inch
Weight
0.7 lbs
Materials
Polyester fleece, elastic
Cover included
Yes
Guarantee
Not specified
Dourxi Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress, Dual Sided Sleep System, Firm Side for Infants and Plush Soft Side for Toddlers, Breathable Foam Baby Mattress with Removable Cover
Score
8.4
MSRP
$109.99
Size
27.5 x 5.5 inches
Weight
11.9 lbs
Materials
Organic cotton, eco foam
Cover included
Yes
Guarantee
10-year warranty

Buying a baby crib is one of the most important purchases you’ll have to make as a new parent. No pressure. 

But what no one ever talks about is the baby crib mattress that you’ll need, and this is an item that’s just as important as having the right crib.

What should you look for in a baby crib mattress? It should be durable and safe to ensure that your baby has sweet dreams while being completely secure. There are other important factors to look out for so that you don’t waste your money while also getting peace of mind. 

Read on to discover the most promising mattresses you can buy for cribs. Let’s start with the best crib mattress: your baby deserves the best, after all.

Now that we’ve looked at the specs of five of the best crib mattresses on the market, let’s take a more in-depth look at what makes them a must for parents to purchase.

Best Overall Winner: Milliard Crib Mattress

If you’re on a budget, one of the trickiest things about purchasing a baby crib mattress is that your baby will grow out of it really fast, requiring you to purchase a new one faster than you would have liked.

This can cause you to not want to spend a lot of money on a baby mattress. This crib mattress by Milliard eradicates that problem. Here’s why.

Extra Features

  • The crib mattress comes with an anti-slip cover that’s made of natural cotton and is resistant to liquid while also being hypoallergenic.
  • It also doesn’t bunch up, but rather stays in place.
  • For the utmost convenience, the mattress is compressed in a box so it’s easy to unpack and set up. Although this is a standard feature for quite a few mattresses on the market that you buy online, it’s still a nice one to mention!

Pros

  • This crib mattress is double-sided so that both newborns and toddlers can use it.
  • Of course, babies and toddlers have different sleep needs when it comes to support. But the Milliard mattress offers both the guarantee of a good night’s sleep: the mattress has a breathable foam layer to offer support and comfort to your infant, while the contouring memory foam layer offers the right support for your toddler’s neck and back.
  • In addition to being suitable for both babies and toddlers, this mattress has been manufactured with CertiPUR-US certified polyurethane foam so you can be assured of its quality and safety.

Cons

  • Although users have reported that the memory foam is made of high quality, some people have said that their mattresses released a chemical smell. However, some of those who reported this drawback did mention that it disappears after a while. To quicken the process, make sure you leave the mattress in a well-ventilated room of the house for a few days before putting it in your crib.

Buying Guide

This Milliard crib mattress costs about $75. 

It’s the best infant mattress because it’s cost effective while offering you the most important things you need in a baby crib mattress, with the bonus of giving you greater versatility thanks to it being a dual-sided mattress.

#2 Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress in a Box

Graco Premium Foam Crib Review

While having a double-sided mattress for your baby’s crib does seem like the gold standard, there are other great crib mattresses out there.

Here’s our runner up product: Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress. Let’s jump into its benefits!

Extra Features

  • It gets delivered to you in a box that’s easy to carry, for the most convenience.
  • The crib mattress has a cover that’s resistant to water while being hand-washable and easy to remove from the mattress on laundry day.

Pros

  • This mattress is Greenguard Gold Certified, while being free of harmful toxins such as lead, mercury, and phthalates.
  • If you’re uncertain of its worth, consider this: it was awarded the 2020 Women’s Choice Award for customer recommended cribs and mattresses.
  • It has a core that’s made out of high quality foam that’s also breathable to increase air circulation in your baby’s bed.
  • As a bonus, it can fit any standard full-size toddler bed or crib.

Cons

  • Some people who purchased this crib mattress have reported that theirs didn’t completely expand. However, it’s important to give the mattress enough time to expand for best results, so you should leave it in a well-ventilated room for 48 hours. One user also recommended flipping the mattress after the first 24 hours in its expansion process to help it along.

Buying Guide

This Graco mattress costs $80, so it costs almost exactly the same as the previous mattress in our guide.

However, it has some great benefits to ensure better quality sleep for your baby or toddler.

Choose it if you’re purchasing a baby mattress online and want one that’s renowned for its benefits while being able to fit a variety of mattress sizes.

#3 Dourxi Crib and Toddler Mattress – Ideal Breathable & Quiet Foam Mattress

Dourxi Crib and Toddler Mattress Review

This mattress is a bit more expensive than others on our list, but it does have some positive features.

One of the most important concerns the type of foam that’s been used in its production. Let’s take a look at why it’s so impressive and worthy of a spot on our list.

Extra Features

  • It comes with a soft and breathable cover.
  • You can return the mattress within 100 days if you’re not happy with it, which is a nice bonus from the manufacturer.

Pros

  • This crib mattress is made of polyurethane foam at its center. This gives your baby or toddler enough support during sleep. It also makes use of Airflow technology to improve air circulation, which is important to ensure comfortable sleep.
  • Not just made of polyurethane, the foam is also of the high-density variety to give your baby the comfort and support he or she needs for restful, uninterrupted sleep.
  • It has been tested to meet all the US safety standards that include being flame-resistant as well as not containing toxins such as lead and phthalates.

Cons

  • Although the cover feels soft, it isn’t waterproof so if your baby or toddler has accidents during the night this won’t protect your mattress against stains and damage. You’ll have to purchase a waterproof cover for your mattress separately.
  • Some users have reported that the mattress didn’t expand properly, which left it uneven.

Buying Guide

This mattress by Dourxi costs about $90, so it’s a bit more expensive than previous mattresses we’ve featured in our guide, but with all its benefits and features it’s clear to see that it’s been made well and with quality in mind. 

It also comes with a 100-day money back guarantee so you can try it out and return it if you’re not happy, which further makes it the best mattress for cribs.

#4 American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Crib and Toddler Protective Mattress Pad Cover

American Baby Company Waterproof Review

If you need something quick and easy to make your baby’s sleep more comfortable, you might want to invest in a mattress pad instead of a mattress.

This one’s the product to purchase. Here’s why.

Extra Features

  • The cover is machine-washable so you can just throw it in with your regular washing load when it needs to be cleaned.

Pros

  • This mattress pad has a waterproof middle layer, on top of which lies soft polyester fleece.
  • Besides for comfort, the extra benefit of soft polyester is that it doesn’t create crinkling sounds.
  • It’s made with deep reinforced corners as well as elastic around the bottom so that it’s easy to use. The elastic also means that it fits your mattress snugly and will stay in place once it’s been put on.
  • It can fit crib mattresses that are up to six inches thick.

Cons

  • Although it’s waterproof, some users have reported that it’s not 100 percent resistant to water. If your baby or toddler has accidents during the night on a regular basis, this might not be enough to prevent leaks and stains.
  • Although the elastic is a nice addition to the mattress pad, some users have reported that it’s not as durable as they’d have liked.

Buying Guide

This American Baby Company mattress topper costs $13, so it’s a good, cheap alternative if you want to give your baby’s mattress an upgrade but don’t have the money to purchase a new mattress right now. 

#5 Dourxi Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress, Dual Sided Sleep System

Dourxi Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress Review

This is another mattress by Dourxi on our list, but it’s a bit more expensive. However, there are quite a few good reasons for this.

Extra Features

  • It comes with a washable, waterproof cotton cover for increased mattress protection. This will not only ensure comfort and hygiene for your baby, but will make your regular mattress cleaning sessions much more convenient.
  • Users have reported that this foam crib mattress fits their babies’ cribs perfectly, making it versatile and user-friendly.

Pros

  • This Dourxi mattress is made of organic cotton. This has many benefits, such as that it reduces allergens, overheating, as well as bacteria from harming your baby.
  • This is a dual-sided mattress that offers comfortable sleep for both toddlers and infants. You get a firmer side for babies and a more cushioned side for toddlers, so both sides have the right amount of support based on your child’s developmental requirements.
  • It’s free of harmful chemicals such as phthalates and also meets federal flammability standards. In addition, it’s been CertiPUR and GreenGuard certified to put your mind at ease.
  • The foam that’s used in the manufacturing of this mattress is ultra-lightweight while also being of high quality.

Cons

  • Although people have commented on how the mattress fits well in the crib, other users have reported that it is thinner than other crib mattresses. If you want a thicker crib mattress, then this is something you need to consider before purchasing the product.

Buying Guide

This mattress costs about $110, so it’s a bit more expensive but it’s definitely worth considering if you’re in the market for a toddler or infant bed that your kids won’t outgrow too quickly. 

Some of the most important features that make this mattress a valuable purchase are that it contains organic cotton, high-quality foam, and the versatility of being turned over when your baby becomes a toddler.

Crib mattresses FAQ

Baby Crib Mattresses

When you embark on shopping for a new baby crib mattress, you might have some questions on your mind. 

Let’s look at some common ones and provide the information you need to know when it comes to how to choose a crib mattress.

How much on average does a mattress for a crib cost?

When shopping for a crib mattress, price is an important factor. On average, you can expect to pay between $90 and $200 for a good mattress. 

On the other hand, if you’re looking at mattresses that contain foam or are of the innerspring mattress varieties, you’ll find mattresses that range from $50 to $400, as Consumer Reports states.

However, your mattress doesn’t have to be that expensive in order to give you a safe, healthy option for your baby. 

As can be seen in our buying guide of the top crib mattresses, mattresses range from $72 to $109, so they are more budget-friendly than other mattresses you’ll find out there but without compromising on the quality you’re looking for in a crib mattress.

What size are average crib mattresses?

Average Crib Matress Size

The average crib mattress will be 28 inches wide and 52 inches long, as Baby Bedding reports. 

However, it’s also worth bearing in mind that there are certain recommendations to follow when it comes to buying baby mattresses in order to ensure that they’re safe for your infant.

As the federal government reports, the size of the safest crib mattress should be a minimum of 27 and ¼ inches by 51 5/8 inches. The thickness of the mattress isn’t meant to be greater than six inches, as Colgate reports.

Are toddler and crib mattresses the same?

When choosing a baby crib mattress, you might worry that you’ll have to change it for something different as your baby grows.

What happens when your infant becomes a toddler? Will he or she need a new mattress?

Don’t worry about having to buy a new mattress in a hurry when your baby reaches his or her toddler stage.

This is because most of the crib mattresses you’ll find on the market are the same size as mattresses that are made for toddlers, as Baby Bedding reports.

So then, what’s the difference? It all comes down to the sheeting you need to use and the fact that a crib is enclosed whereas a toddler bed is open.

When it comes to sheeting, as your baby becomes a toddler, it’s important to add top sheets as well as comforters for greater support and comfort.

In our buying guide of crib mattresses, we’ve featured some products that can be used for both infants and toddlers, which give you further convenience.

An example of such a product is the Milliard crib mattress that is double-sided for both age groups, thus increasing the lifespan of your crib mattress for many years without compromising on comfort.

How to protect your crib mattress?

Protect Your Mattress From Stains

Once you’ve purchased a crib mattress, it’s essential that you look after it so that it can last you a long time. Ensuring that it’s well maintained will also make it safer for your baby to use.

One of the most important things you can do to keep your baby mattress healthy and clean is to use a mattress cover on it. 

All of the crib mattresses featured in our buying guide come with covers included, which is great because you don’t have to go out and purchase a cover separately. It’s clear to see that mattress covers are non-negotiable if you want to keep your mattress in good condition.

When buying a mattress with a cover, make sure that the cover has the following important factors.

  • It should be resistant to liquids, thus protecting your mattress against accidents your baby or toddler could have during the night.
  • It should be hypoallergenic to prevent allergens.
  • It’s a nice bonus if it prevents slipping and bunching. An example can be found in the anti-slip cover that comes with the Milliard Crib Mattress, which is also made from organic cotton for greater comfort.

Before you put your baby mattress in its crib, you should air it out.

This removes funny odors in it that can be as a result of chemicals that were used in the manufacturing of the mattress.

Put it in a well-ventilated room for a few days before use to give it the ventilation it needs.

You should clean your baby mattress regularly by vacuuming it to remove debris and dust. When doing this, don’t forget to clean your crib at the same time to properly rid your baby’s bed of allergens and irritants. 

You can also disinfect it, but ensure that you use baby-safe laundry detergent and choose organic products to maintain your baby’s health.

Here’s a quick and easy way to clean and disinfect your baby’s mattress:

  • Put ¼ cup of baby-safe laundry detergent in a container with one gallon of warm water.
  • With the use of a gentle brush, scrub the mattress fabric with this solution. However, make sure you don’t pour the water or detergent on the mattress directly. If you have a foam mattress, it’s even more important not to get it too wet.
  • Wipe down the mattress with a damp cloth so that you remove the detergent residue.
  • If you’ve cleaned the mattress but it has stains, then you want to get rid of them. To clean stains, such as from urine, you can mix together equal amounts of lemon juice, water, and vinegar. Put them in a spray bottle and spray this liquid onto the mattress stains. Then, put baking soda onto the stains to remove any leftover odors from them. Leave it on for about half an hour, then vacuum your dry mattress.

Conclusion

Buying a crib mattress isn’t an easy task.

You might worry about purchasing the wrong one, and, indeed, it is very important to consider various factors before you make your purchase. 

For example, you need to make sure that the mattress is the right size to ensure safety for your baby, that it’s free of harmful chemicals, and that it’s made with baby support in mind.

You might also wish to purchase a mattress that can be used by both babies and toddlers.

Did you like the article? Please rate it:

You Might Also Like​

Sleeping on the Floor: Pros and Cons

Read More →
Definitive Guide To Cribs

Definitive Guide To Cribs

Read More →
How To Fix A Sagging Mattress (Tips And Tricks)

How To Fix A Sagging Mattress (Tips and tricks)

Read More →